Politics
Trump withdraws FDA pick as Senate blocks vote on NSF nominee amid science concerns
The withdrawal of the FDA nominee and cancellation of an NSF confirmation vote reflect growing pushback over the administration's scientific leadership choices.
Ars Technica
The Trump administration's efforts to fill two major science leadership roles have stalled as the Senate blocked confirmation votes and withdrew one nomination amid criticism about the candidates' scientific credentials and independence.
FDA nominee exits the race#
Trump's pick to lead the Food and Drug Administration stepped back from the nomination process, citing the compressed legislative calendar. Senator Bill Cassidy, who leads the Senate health committee, indicated that Democrats in the chamber would inherit responsibility for nominating a permanent FDA chief, given the limited time remaining for the current Congress to act.
NSF candidate rejected over science independence concerns#
The same committee canceled a scheduled confirmation vote for Jim O'Neill, Trump's choice to run the National Science Foundation. The blockade reflected concerns from lawmakers that O'Neill has insufficient scientific background and, more critically, failed to defend scientific integrity within the administration.
O'Neill's career spans Silicon Valley venture capital and entrepreneurship, and he became closely aligned with tech investor Peter Thiel. More recently, he has served as deputy secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services and acting director of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
His tenure at the CDC drew particular scrutiny. He took charge after Susan Monarez—who had just been confirmed—was fired from the role. According to Monarez's later account to lawmakers, Kennedy, the health secretary, terminated her for resisting pressure to rubber-stamp vaccine recommendations from his anti-vaccine advisors.
Cassidy cited this episode as a failure of leadership, stating that O'Neill "did not do enough to stand up for science and against irresponsible decisions and statements" from Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. He emphasized that the moment demands "leadership and fortitude and standing up for what is right."
Broader damage to federal science infrastructure#
The NSF has endured severe disruption over the past two years. The foundation has canceled hundreds of research grants, slashed its budget and workforce substantially, and lost all members of its governing National Science Board after Trump terminated them in April. Critics worried the board purge would enable O'Neill to stock it with political loyalists rather than accomplished researchers.

