Policy
Democrats stage boycott over FCC nominee picked to shift panel toward Trump
All 13 Democratic members of the Senate commerce committee skipped a vote advancing Danielle Thumann Severs, Brendan Carr's aide, over concerns the move would let Trump dismiss the agency's sole Democratic commissioner.
1/2
The Verge
Every Democratic seat on the Senate commerce committee sat empty Wednesday as Republicans advanced President Trump's nominee to join the Federal Communications Commission. The 15-member Republican contingent, led by Committee Chair Ted Cruz, voted unanimously to move Danielle Thumann Severs to a full Senate floor vote, while all 13 Democrats boycotted the proceeding.
Why Democrats walked out#
The protest centers on concerns that confirming Thumann would allow Trump to reshape the FCC without Democratic input. Currently the agency has four members: three Republicans and one Democrat, Anna Gomez. Democrats say Gomez's expired term means she could be removed if the Republican count reaches three—a quorum Trump could then use to push through regulatory changes without obstruction.
Democrats asked Cruz to delay the vote until a Democratic nominee could be paired with Thumann's confirmation, a practice common for historically independent agencies. The White House has not put forward any Democratic nominees. "This is not a problem we created, but a problem that the White House can solve," Democrats said in statements.
Factual disputes over Thumann's record#
Senator Ben Ray Luján raised additional red flags about Thumann's honesty during the confirmation process. At a November hearing, Thumann testified she had not worked on media-related matters as senior counsel to FCC Chair Brendan Carr. However, documents obtained through Freedom of Information Act requests showed she was involved in several high-profile media cases—including helping draft commitments that led to the FCC's approval of the Skydance-Paramount merger, handling complaints about CBS's 60 Minutes, and responding to a controversy involving Jimmy Kimmel.
Luján accused Thumann of misleading the committee. "If she was lying about this, what else is she lying about and what else is she hiding?" he told reporters.
Republicans defend the nomination#
Cruz acknowledged concerns about Carr's past handling of the Kimmel incident but said he was satisfied with Thumann's explanations. He characterized her confirmation as "an ordinary nomination to fill a vacancy previously held by someone in the same party" and noted that Trump has not moved to remove any Democratic FCC commissioners, as he did at the Federal Trade Commission.
Republican Senator Jerry Moran said a morning phone call with Thumann reassured him about her commitment to free speech protections. The committee previously passed Cruz's JAWBONE Act, which would allow individuals to sue government officials over alleged First Amendment violations.

