Security
New Framework Breaks Down Authentication Quality into Measurable Components
AQUA offers researchers a structured way to pinpoint which features of authentication systems affect security, usability, and other performance metrics.
Researchers have introduced AQUA, a modular framework designed to help evaluate and understand the quality of authentication systems by isolating the impact of different design elements.
The Problem with Current Assessment#
When studying authentication solutions—whether passwords, multi-factor authentication, or passkeys—researchers struggle to identify which specific components drive improvements or degradations in security and usability. For instance, adding a second authentication factor improves security but often makes the system harder to use, yet distinguishing whether the usability hit comes from the combined approach itself or from inherent properties of the second factor remains difficult.
How AQUA Works#
The framework decomposes authentication into four interconnected layers, each with its own quality characteristics:
- Authenticators — the tools or methods users employ (biometric scanners, passwords, security keys)
- Authentication techniques — how those authenticators are combined and deployed
- Authentication solutions — the complete system as experienced by end users
- Quality models — measurable properties that span each level
By structuring authentication this way, researchers can trace quality effects to their origin point and understand how improvements or problems cascade through the system.
Practical Application and Future Directions#
The team developed initial quality models covering authenticators, techniques, and complete solutions, then demonstrated how quality propagates across these layers using concrete examples and usability metrics. This modular approach creates a foundation for building automated assessment tools, predictive models for new authentication designs, and standardized benchmarks for comparing different authentication approaches.
The work, submitted to arXiv in early November 2026, aims to support both researchers and practitioners designing more secure and user-friendly authentication systems.

