Autonomous Vehicles & Regulation
U.S. States Pursue Wildly Different Paths for Self-Driving Car Approval, New Study Finds
Without a unified federal framework, American states are adopting three distinct models to certify and oversee autonomous vehicle deployments, ranging from minimal oversight to formal agency review.
The United States lacks a cohesive national system for authorizing self-driving cars, leaving individual states to devise their own approaches to regulating autonomous vehicle (AV) testing and deployment. A new academic analysis of this regulatory fragmentation reveals the extent of the variation and suggests how states like North Carolina might tighten their oversight in the future.
Three Distinct State Models Emerge#
Researchers examined how ten states regulate high-level autonomous driving systems (SAE Levels 4–5) and found three distinct certification models:
- Baseline legal compliance: States set general legal requirements but impose minimal formal oversight, relying largely on companies to self-police.
- Administrative self-certification with oversight: States require companies to certify their own readiness while regulatory agencies maintain some ongoing monitoring.
- Permit-based authorization: States demand formal agency review and approval before any autonomous vehicle can be deployed.
North Carolina currently operates under the first, least restrictive model. The range of approaches suggests that some states are comfortable with lighter-touch regulation, while others are moving toward tighter controls.
What International Standards Look Like#
Regulators in the European Union, China, Japan, and Australia are converging on tougher, more detailed frameworks. These include scenario-based testing, approval specific to each vehicle's intended operating environment, formal safety-case documentation, cybersecurity checks, and continuous oversight throughout the vehicle's lifespan. However, the researchers caution that wholesale adoption of these international standards may not work directly in the U.S. context.
Why This Matters#
The absence of federal guidance creates incentives for regulatory arbitrage—companies may relocate testing to states with looser rules. It also leaves consumers and policymakers in some jurisdictions with less assurance about AV safety and performance. As autonomous vehicle deployments expand nationwide, pressure may mount for greater consistency, either through federal action or through states learning from and harmonizing their approaches with one another.

